Spread the love

Plant-shopping is a hobby for most addicted gardeners, but it’s also a craft. Years ago, when I wanted to sharpen my skills, I consulted with the buyer for a busy Long Island landscape installation company; this company depended for its reputation on installing only first class plants. The buyer generously shared his checklist for plant evaluation, which I still take with me to the nursery whenever I go.

  1. When shopping for deciduous trees or shrubs, look for leaves that are torn or brown along the margin – this is likely to be a sign of trauma the plant experienced during shipment from the grower to the retailer. If handled carelessly during shipment, a plant may experience dehydration, scalding sun and hurricane-force winds in the back of an open truck. Sure, the plant may recover from this, but why take a chance?
  2. Check for yellowed leaves – these are commonly a sign of damaged roots. This can happen if the nursery help is less than conscientious about watering or if the plant is left in a too-sunny, too-hot spot. If the nursery staff will allow it, slip the plant out of its container – the root tips at the outside of the ball should be crisp and white, not brown or black.
  3. When shopping for trees, check the trunk. There should be neither bruises or cuts in the bark or the scars of old injuries. Such an injury, the legacy of rough handling, is an entry point for diseases and decay.
  4. Check for stubs of cut-back branches. At best this is evidence of unskilled pruning and symptomatic of poor care while the shrub was grown. At worst, it suggests that at some point the shrub or tree suffered some sort of die-back and the grower simply hacked it back rather than discarding the unhealthy specimen.

    Branch stub is evidence of poor pruning and dieback

  5. When shopping for conifers, run a hand over the needles. If they feel dry, that’s an indication that the plant has been allowed to dehydrate at some point and the roots were damaged. Conifers rarely recover from this kind of stress.
  6. Check the rootball of B&B (balled and burlapped) trees or shrubs.   A sagging or flattened ball, or rotting burlap, suggests the plant has been sitting in the nursery yard for a long time, which dramatically reduces its chance of surviving transplanting.

    Rotting burlap and dead roots are clues this plant has been in the nursery yard too long

  7. Buy young. Large, bargain-priced specimens may be appealing but they suffer more from transplanting and even if they don’t die subsequently they are likely to sulk. Younger plants tolerate transplanting better and will recover and resume growth much faster so that within a few years they are likely to outgrow the larger specimen. This makes the smaller plants a double bargain, as they are also cheaper, typically, at the time of purchase.

If you have any favorite shopping tips, please share!

Posted by

Thomas Christopher
on April 18, 2016 at 9:41 am, in the category It’s the Plants, Darling, Taking Your Gardening Dollar.

  • A Growing Trend in the U.S.: Food Forests

    Spread the love Mound-forming alpine strawberries (Fragaria vesca) tolerate a range of soi…
Load More By R
  • Sticker shock

    Spread the love Raise your hand if you enjoy spending up to half an hour removing adhesive…
  • How I learned to stop worrying and love gardening indoors

    Spread the love This was taken in February of last year. At some point, I have to admit th…
  • Garden Ephemera

    Spread the love The ephemeral flight of hot air balloons over my garden just after sunrise…
Load More In Shut Up And Dig


  1. ruth rogers clausen

    23rd January 2016 at 2:59 pm

    More consumers should take heed of these tips. Plants that don’t thrive in home gardens are one of the big reasons why gardeners, especially novices, do not come back for more plants. A plant is only a bargain if it thrives when you have it planted in the ground at home, and have given it good care and nurturing.

  2. Elizabeth Licata

    26th April 2016 at 4:00 am

    Great tips! Do you have similar lists for perennials and annuals?

  3. Thomas Christopher

    2nd August 2016 at 12:25 pm

    I do — I can post them at some later date.

  4. Renee Beaulieu

    4th September 2016 at 3:28 am

    It’s become difficult to find b&b that are grown properly. Way too often, soil has been piled up around the trunk as the tree is root-pruned every year. I’ve removed 6+ inches to find the flare. On one red maple, there were literally no roots left by the time we reached the flare, a foot down. It’s a huge waste of time to have to return a crappy plant, and hope the replacement isn’t as bad. I’ve stopped buying b&b for that reason and stick with container-grown. At least in a container you can usually find the flare. In the nursery, instead of on-site.

Leave a Reply

Check Also

A Growing Trend in the U.S.: Food Forests

Spread the love Mound-forming alpine strawberries (Fragaria vesca) tolerate a range of soi…